ITA Wealth Management

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Lifetime ITA Membership
  • Portfolios
    • Bethe Portfolio
    • Bohr Portfolio
    • Carson Portfolios
    • Dirac Portfolio
    • Einstein Portfolio
    • Franklin Portfolio
    • Galileo Portfolio
    • Gauss Portfolio
    • Huygens Portfolio
    • Kahneman-Tversky Portfolio
    • Kepler Portfolio
    • McClintock Portfolio
    • Millikan Portfolio
    • Pauling Portfolio
    • Rutherford Portfolio
    • Schrodinger Portfolio
  • Forum
  • Reset Password
  • Contact Me
  • ITA Feedback
  • About Me
You are here: Home / Beginning Investors / How Many Assets Should I Hold In My Portfolio?

How Many Assets Should I Hold In My Portfolio?

October 27, 2013 By HedgeHunter

This question has been asked in a number of Blog Posts and we pussy-foot around it because there really is no definitive answer. On the one hand we need enough to give us an adequate level of diversification (whatever that means) to reduce volatility (risk) while keeping our commissions, management costs and fees to a minimum.

We maybe start out by thinking of diversification as “more is better”, progress to thinking of it in terms of different asset classes (Equities, Bonds, REITS, Commodities, Metals,…etc), then, recognizing that even this does not necessarily guarantee that we are diversified, we may look closer at correlations and  “clustering”.

Also, we all have different investment styles – Strategic Asset Allocation (SAA) requires us to make discretionary decisions as to which assets to hold and the allocation to be made to each asset – Portfolio Optimization reduces the discretionary limits to a degree and calculates “recommended” allocations to different assets/asset classes – momentum tends to dominate diversification decisions to some extent and leave the discretionary decisions to allocation weightings.

I recently found the following figure in one of Gary Antonacci’s articles on “Key Momentum Factors”.

Momentum - Number of Assets

This shows that portfolio volatility drops rapidly (exponentially) as we increase the number of assets from 1-5, but that adding more assets beyond this level has little impact. On the other side of the equation, returns (based on momentum) tend to drop in a more linear manner – thus there will be an optimal balance in terms of return/risk – this provides a good explanation for the excellent performance of the Feynman Max4 Portfolio.

Let me play Devil’s Advocate and suggest that (from a “scientific” point-of-view) it may not be advantageous to construct portfolios containing more than 4 or 5 assets (remembering that these assets are already “diversified” ETFs).

This should be good for discussion – please don’t “shoot the messenger”, remember I’m playing Devil’s Advocate – disclosure – I don’t (presently) have any portfolios with so few assets.

(Visited 251 times, 1 visits today)

Filed Under: Beginning Investors, Portfolio Construction Tagged With: Portfolio Construction

Comments

  1. Lowell Herr says

    October 27, 2013 at 8:22 AM

    David,

    Let me ask the first question to this post. Did Antonacci mention if his graph refers to individual stocks or to index funds such as ETFs?

    Lowell

    • HedgeHunter says

      October 27, 2013 at 10:41 AM

      Lowell,

      Antonacci uses ETFs – I believe almost exclusively – at least in his articles.

      David

  2. Lowell Herr says

    October 27, 2013 at 8:32 AM

    ITA Readers: There is an excellent book that parallels the above argument. “How A Second Grader Beats Wall Street” by Allan S. Roth is all about a portfolio made up of three index funds. They are: VTSMX, VGTSX, and VBMFX. These three funds cover the entire U.S. Equities market, total international equities market, and total bond market.

    Lowell

    • Charles Crane says

      October 27, 2013 at 9:00 AM

      David / Lowell,

      I’m an ex-Boglehead and used the simple 3 fund portfolio VTSMX, VGTSX, and VBMFX. It did fine, but got clobbered in ’08 and that’s when I decided against ‘buy and hold’ and started searching for alternatives. The BH mantra is “Tune out the noise” and “Stay the course”. Sorry, but just can’t do that, simple as it sounds.

      Re: Diversification – Used to be that a 60/40 port the 40% bonds were your main diversifier. Not any longer however. So bonds are pretty much useless (to me) at this point in time. That leaves US vs Int’l equities, REIT’s, commodities etc.

      I then read a couple of Sy Harding books. He has a portfolio of exactly ONE ETF; DIA. He goes ‘all in’ in mid-Oct and all out (cash) end of April. I’ve done some backtesting with this seasonal phenomenon and find, oddly enough, that his theory / practice has worked for him and others.

      I then read ‘The IVY Portfolio” which uses 5 ETFS and monitors a 200 day moving average.

      So, I’m in transit…. looking for the best approach to get me OUT of the market before a major fall. As for getting in, right now, things are SO overvalued that it’s hard to pull the trigger on anything. Wife and I are sitting on a huge pile of cash in our 401k’s / ROTH’s waiting for a good time to move a sizeable amount back into action.

      Interesting times for investing for sure.

      • Lowell Herr says

        October 27, 2013 at 9:11 AM

        Charles,

        On the original blog I think I might have a few entries on Sy Harding’s model. He now adds or uses a MACD overlay to his seasonal model. If you search for MACD on the original blog you will find how Gerald Appel’s MACD is calculated. Appel published these results back around 1979 and I have his original booklet on this subject. The booklet even includes instructions how to program the TI-81 to come with the results. Now we just use the Internet. (g)

        Lowell

      • HedgeHunter says

        October 27, 2013 at 10:54 AM

        Mitch,

        That’s why I spent a lot of time on Part 6 of the Feynman Study and tried to stress the importance of Risk Management. Although my personal preference is to use the SHY Filter, a MA is good too – just do something, no matter how simple, to insure the Buy and Hold. See Part 6.2.2 of the Feynman Study for an example of effectiveness with a “Buy and Hold” (although not quite at this point) Portfolio.

        If an Investor (probably not you) just wants to Buy and Hold a portfolio of assets without selling anything and doesn’t have time to monitor the portfolio, it might still be advisable to buy an annual insurance policy (Put Option) for portfolio protection. It will reduce returns but at least it will avoid devastating drawdowns.

        David

      • HedgeHunter says

        October 27, 2013 at 10:58 AM

        Mitch,

        I’m doing some work on “Seasonality” right now – but it’s more focused on my Options Trading than on my (retirement) investments – just another way I, personally, bring diversification into the equation.

        David

  3. Richard Yalmokas says

    October 27, 2013 at 9:24 AM

    Lowell:
    As I read Antonacci, including the paper you reference, and his other papers, he is talking about ETFs.
    Dick

  4. Charles Crane says

    October 27, 2013 at 12:35 PM

    Lowell, I use MACD and RSI after getting the weighted suggestions for further evaluation.

    There is nice little (FREE) excel SS here:

    http://investexcel.net/4280/make-winning-trades-macd/

    On my Portfolio page I have hyperlinks to saved MACD / RSI files of each ETF. Very handy.

    http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y221/ccrane/INVEST/ScreenHunter_04Oct241450_zps56795a3a.jpg

  5. Charles Crane says

    October 27, 2013 at 1:08 PM

    FYI, here are a couple of links… 1 to a youtube video with a walk-through on how to build the Seasonal Anomolies SS and a screenshot of Vanguard Total Stock Market using the SS and data back to 1996.

    http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y221/ccrane/INVEST/ScreenHunter_02Oct121528_zpsd5ecca5f.jpg

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CVl6STLqD_s&list=UUTPOMEWVghQOMKl8W18Jisw&index=10

  6. Charles Crane says

    October 27, 2013 at 1:10 PM

    Opps…wrong youtube, here is the one I meant to post:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CVl6STLqD_s&list=UUTPOMEWVghQOMKl8W18Jisw

  7. Charles Crane says

    October 27, 2013 at 1:13 PM

    WELL Dang…what’s going on here ? Sure wish I could edit posts instead of having to post new ones.

    Market Anomalies:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CVl6STLqD_s

    • Lowell Herr says

      October 27, 2013 at 1:50 PM

      Charles,

      Thanks for the links. I watched these videos some weeks ago and found them quite interesting.

      As for editing your comment, you should see an Edit option just to the right of the time stamp near the top of your comment. See if it is available to you as it is for me.

      Lowell

      • Charles Crane says

        October 27, 2013 at 2:28 PM

        Lowell, I do not see and edit button / link anywhere.

        • Lowell Herr says

          October 28, 2013 at 2:12 AM

          That is strange as I see an Edit option on every one of these comments. That might be due to my administrative control over the blog.

          Lowell

          • HedgeHunter says

            October 28, 2013 at 5:05 AM

            Lowell,

            I think that’s the answer Lowell – I see the edit option but I also have admin control.

            David

  8. Charles Crane says

    October 27, 2013 at 1:15 PM

    AND…the correct VTSMX screenshot: (yikes, sorry guys!)

    http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y221/ccrane/INVEST/ScreenHunter_01Oct051216_zps2598467a.jpg

  9. Charles Crane says

    October 27, 2013 at 4:29 PM

    Lowell,

    I do not see any edit button / link anywhere here or in the forum.

Categories

Search

Recent Posts

  • Kepler Interim Look: 23 January 2021
  • Rutherford Portfolio Review (Tranche 3) – 22 January 2021
  • Millikan Portfolio Update: 22 January 2021
  • Maintaining Risk Ratios: Camtasia Video Available
  • Pauling Portfolio Review: 21 January 2021

Recent Comments

  • HedgeHunter on Rutherford Portfolio Review (Tranche 3) – 22 January 2021
  • Lowell Herr on Kepler Interim Look: 23 January 2021
  • Steven Lefley on Kepler Interim Look: 23 January 2021
  • Lowell Herr on Kepler Interim Look: 23 January 2021
  • Jim Hotvedt on Kepler Interim Look: 23 January 2021
  • Jim Hotvedt on Rutherford Portfolio Review (Tranche 3) – 22 January 2021
  • HedgeHunter on Rutherford Portfolio Review (Tranche 2) – 15 January 2021
  • Lowell Herr on Maintaining Risk Ratios: Camtasia Video Available
  • Lowell Herr on Pauling Portfolio Review: 21 January 2021
  • Lowell Herr on Bohr Portfolio Interim Update: 17 January 2021
  • Jim Hotvedt on Size and Style Factor Breakdown of US Equity Markets
  • Lowell Herr on Size and Style Factor Breakdown of US Equity Markets
  • Lowell Herr on Bethe Portfolio Checkup: 16 January 2021
  • LiftLock on Bethe Portfolio Checkup: 16 January 2021
  • Lowell Herr on Bethe Portfolio Checkup: 16 January 2021

Links

Blogroll
  • A Wealth of Common Sense
  • Advisor Perspectives
  • ETF Replay
  • ETF Research Center
Investing Information
  • Archives
  • Feynman Study
  • Portfolio Charts
  • Portfolio Visualizer
  • Seeking Alpha
  • Shiller CAPE Ratio
  • Stock Charts
  • William J. Bernstein Portfolios
Top Investing Blogs
  • A Wealth of Common Sense
  • Collaborative Fund
  • ETF Daily News
  • ETF.com
  • The Big Picture

Archives

Calendar

January 2021
S M T W T F S
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  
« Dec    

Users Online

13 Users Online
Users: LiftLock, Tom Pulaski, HedgeHunter, 2 Guests, 8 Bots

Most Popular Posts

  • Dirac Portfolio Review – 31 December 2020 (265)
  • Understanding The New Kipling Spreadsheet (217)
  • Portfolio Construction For 2021 (170)
  • Asset Allocation Feature of the Kipling Spreadsheet (155)
  • What Is A Good Sortino Ratio? (133)
  • Sample Carson IRR Comparisons (113)
  • Kepler ETF Rankings (111)
  • Is The Dual Momentum System Broken? (103)
  • Seasonality: Sell in May and Go Away (91)
  • Bullish Percent Indicators: 27 November 2020 (87)

General Investment News

Portfolios coming up for review are:  Euclid, Bethe, and Carson Trio.  Non-scheduled portfolios may be reviewed.  If you are a new user, check the posts you missed. Links to Random Posts are found in the lower right-hand footer or just to the right of what you are now reading.  Most popular posts are found in the lower left-hand footer.

Contact me at itawealth@comcast.net if interested in a Lifetime Membership.  Current Platinum members will be grandfathered into a Lifetime Membership in the summer of 2021.

Random Posts

  • Kepler Update
  • Asset Allocation – Risk Parity Revisited: Part 3
  • Portfolio Performance Data: 4 April 2015
  • History of ITA Wealth Management
  • Galileo Portfolio: A Dual Momentum Model
  • Galileo Portfolio Review: 7 September 2016
  • Portfolio Performance Data: 1 April 2016
  • Value-Momentum Stocks: Possible Additions for Some Portfolios
  • Galileo Portfolio Review: 13 November 2014
  • ETF Rankings and Cluster Analysis for Week of September 6th

Log in | Website Design by BOING